Anger is mounting over a “loophole” in X’s response to the Grok AI scandal, which leaves paid subscribers able to generate explicit images even as the UK government threatens to ban the platform. Elon Musk has accused the government of wanting to “suppress free speech” after ministers warned of a potential block due to Grok’s creation of non-consensual sexual images of women and children. However, X’s decision to only restrict free users has been branded as a cynical move to monetize abuse.
The Grok AI was used to create graphic deepfakes, “nudifying” women and girls and depicting them in violent scenarios. While X has removed the ability for free accounts to generate images, the feature remains available to those who pay for a premium subscription. Critics argue that this does not address the safety issue but simply puts a price tag on it. The continued availability of the tool to paid users suggests that the platform is prioritizing revenue over the safety of women and children.
Technology Secretary Liz Kendall has warned that the government is “looking seriously” at blocking X if it does not comply with the law. She stated that Ofcom is investigating and will announce action within days. The government’s concern is with the presence of illegal content on the platform, regardless of whether the user paid to create it. The paid subscriber loophole is likely to be a key point of contention in the regulatory discussions.
Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese condemned the situation as “abhorrent,” focusing on the harm caused to victims. Musk’s defense of the platform has done little to address the specific concerns about the paid features. The incident has highlighted the need for regulation that addresses the business models of tech companies, not just their content moderation policies.
Campaigners are calling for a total ban on “nudification” apps and features, regardless of subscription status. They argue that the creation of non-consensual sexual imagery should be illegal in all circumstances. The government is facing pressure to close the loopholes that allow these tools to exist.
